Bay Island Siesta Key Real Estate

Bay Island real estate at the North end of Siesta Key is considered prime waterfront and canal front property. Homes boast unbelievable views of the Sarasota skyline and the bay. Bay Island homes range from 1930’s cottages, 1950’s bungalows, to modern estates.

Browse current listings for Bay Island real estate, or read more about the amenities in this gorgeous Siesta Key community.

Bay Island Homes for Sale

6 Properties Found. Showing Page 1 of 1
View As: Thumbnails List Tabular Map
Sort by:
Status Price Type City Bed Bath Subdiv Address SqFt
Incredible North Siest...
Status:
Not FC
Price:
$3,099,000
Type:
Single Family Home
City:
Siesta Key
Beds:
4
Baths:
4
Subdiv:
Bay Island Shores
Address:
3535 Flamingo Ave
SqFt:
4,103
Location, Location, Lo...
Status:
Not FC
Price:
$1,995,000
Type:
Single Family Home
City:
Siesta Key
Beds:
3
Baths:
2
Subdiv:
Bay Island Shores
Address:
763 Freeling Dr
SqFt:
1,616
Breathtaking Roberts B...
Status:
Not FC
Price:
$1,750,000
Type:
Single Family Home
City:
Siesta Key
Beds:
3
Baths:
2
Subdiv:
Bay Island Shores
Address:
830 Siesta Dr
SqFt:
2,499
Coastal Living At Its ...
Status:
Not FC
Price:
$879,900
Type:
Single Family Home
City:
Siesta Key
Beds:
4
Baths:
4
Subdiv:
Bay Island
Address:
708 Norsota Way
SqFt:
2,616
A Most Unique Property...
Status:
Not FC
Price:
$769,000
Type:
Single Family Home
City:
Siesta Key
Beds:
3
Baths:
2
Subdiv:
Bay Island
Address:
779 Siesta Dr
SqFt:
1,888
Only Minutes From The ...
Status:
Not FC
Price:
$675,000
Type:
Single Family Home
City:
Siesta Key
Beds:
4
Baths:
2
Subdiv:
Bay Island
Address:
749 Siesta Dr
SqFt:
2,614
Status: Not FC = Not Foreclosure, SS = Short Sale, BO = Bank Owned

Incredible North Siest...

$3,099,000
Siesta Key, FL
4 br, 4 ba, 4,103 ft², Single Family Home Residential
Price:
$3,099,000
Waterfrontage
Waterview
City:
Siesta Key
DOM:
326 DOM
Type:
Single Family Home
Beds:
4 br,
Baths:
4 ba
Subdiv:
Bay Island Shor
SqFt:
4,103 SqFt

Incredible North Siesta Key Pool Home With Bay Views And Protected Deep Water Boat Basin. This Ho...

Photo of Listing #A4162146

Location, Location, Lo...

$1,995,000
Siesta Key, FL
3 br, 2 ba, 1,616 ft², Single Family Home Residential
Price:
$1,995,000
Waterview
City:
Siesta Key
DOM:
211 DOM
Type:
Single Family Home
Beds:
3 br,
Baths:
2 ba
Subdiv:
Bay Island Shor
SqFt:
1,616 SqFt

Location, Location, Location! * Deep Water! * Protected Harborage * Freeling Drive Is Known For I...

Photo of Listing #A4172756

Breathtaking Roberts B...

$1,750,000
Siesta Key, FL
3 br, 2 ba, 2,499 ft², Single Family Home Residential
Price:
$1,750,000
Waterfrontage
Waterview
City:
Siesta Key
DOM:
23 DOM
Type:
Single Family Home
Beds:
3 br,
Baths:
2 ba
Subdiv:
Bay Island Shor
SqFt:
2,499 SqFt

Breathtaking Roberts Bay Views On Sailboat Water With New Seawall And New Dock. Highly Sought Af...

Photo of Listing #A4190419

Coastal Living At Its ...

$879,900
Siesta Key, FL
4 br, 4 ba, 2,616 ft², Single Family Home Residential
Price:
$879,900
City:
Siesta Key
DOM:
153 DOM
Type:
Single Family Home
Beds:
4 br,
Baths:
4 ba
Subdiv:
Bay Island
SqFt:
2,616 SqFt

Coastal Living At Its Finest! An Exciting Opportunity Awaits You In This Extensively And Professi...

Photo of Listing #A4172972

A Most Unique Property...

$769,000
Siesta Key, FL
3 br, 2 ba, 1,888 ft², Single Family Home Residential
Price:
$769,000
City:
Siesta Key
DOM:
530 DOM
Type:
Single Family Home
Beds:
3 br,
Baths:
2 ba
Subdiv:
Bay Island
SqFt:
1,888 SqFt

A Most Unique Property Located On Siesta Key - Bay Island. 3 Bed 2 Bath. Beautiful Wood Floors, F...

Photo of Listing #A4187578

Only Minutes From The ...

$675,000
Siesta Key, FL
4 br, 2 ba, 2,614 ft², Single Family Home Residential
Price:
$675,000
City:
Siesta Key
DOM:
198 DOM
Type:
Single Family Home
Beds:
4 br,
Baths:
2 ba
Subdiv:
Bay Island
SqFt:
2,614 SqFt

Only Minutes From The Best Beach In Florida ,siesta Key Beach. Large Fenced Lot With Lots Of Room...

Photo of Listing #A4173415

Bay Island Amenities

Boaters have Bay access at their back doors and proximity to Siesta Key beaches, shopping and recreation.

The 3-acre Bay Island Park is a popular fishing and picnic spot for locals.

View other Siesta Key Neighborhoods:

If you would like to view any of the Bay Island listings, or have any questions, please don't hesitate to contact Adam Robinson at (941) 556-5500.

^ Back to Bay Island Real Estate

All listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified through personal inspection by appropriate professionals. Listings displayed on this website may be subject to prior sale or removal from sale; availability of any listing should always be independently verified.

Listing information is provided for consumer personal, non-commercial use, solely to identify potential properties for potential purchase; all other use is strictly prohibited and may violate relevant federal and state law.

Listing data comes from My Florida Regional MLS.

Listing information last updated on July 22nd, 2017 at 6:33pm EDT.

My Account

| Forgotten It?

Recent Blog Posts

Dec31

Siesta Key 2010 Single Family Sales Statistics

30% of Sales are ForeclosuresSiesta Key had a total of 134 single family sales in 2010, of these roughly 30% were distressed foreclosure sales.  This inclu...

2 Comments Read More

Dec31

Just Listed Bank Owned: Gulf and Bay Club

Gulf and Bay Club: Bank OwnedThere is a new bank owned condo listed for sale in the Gulf & Bay ClubThe seller of this bank owned property has requested that...

1 Comments Read More

Dec31

We're Not Talking Sandcastles...

From November 18-21/10 thousands will be flocking to our beaches to view the Siesta Key Crystal Classic - a world class display of sand sculpting. The fine whi...

Add Comment Read More


Sarasota Foreclosures

Visit our foreclosure site to access every bank owned, short sale, and foreclosure in Sarasota. Your password and ID will work on both SarasotaCondos.com and SarasotaForeclosures.com

Sarasota-Foreclosures.com
Email Bookmark and Share